Enamel Pin vs. Soft Enamel Pin: Which Should You Buy?
By Forager Vintage - A Boutique in the heart of Downtown | Published: 2026-10-29
Category: Comparisons
Hard enamel pins have a smooth, glass-like finish and vibrant colors that last. Soft enamel pins have a textured surface and are often more affordable. Here's how to choose.
Quick answer
Choose a hard enamel pin for a smooth, polished look and vivid colors that resist wear. Choose a soft enamel pin for a textured, dimensional feel and a lower price point.
What makes hard enamel different from soft enamel?
Hard enamel pins are made by filling recessed metal areas with enamel that is baked and polished flat, creating a smooth, glass-like surface. Soft enamel pins leave the enamel slightly recessed below the metal lines, giving a textured, tactile feel.
The main trade-off is finish versus cost. Hard enamel requires more steps and materials, so it usually costs more. Soft enamel is quicker to produce and often more budget-friendly, but the surface is not as smooth or durable over time.
Which finish suits your style?
If you prefer a clean, glossy look that catches the light evenly, hard enamel is the way to go. The polished surface makes colors pop and the pin feels substantial. Soft enamel gives a more handcrafted, dimensional look — the metal lines stand out and the enamel has a slight dip.
Both styles have their fans. Hard enamel pins like the Lesbian Pride Phoenix Enamel Pin (2605615) use bright, polished gold metal and hard enamel colors for a striking, heirloom-quality appearance. Soft enamel pins, such as the Spotted Skunk Enamel Pin (2605604), offer a charming textured finish with a delicate charm.
Hard enamel vs soft enamel: key trade-offs
- Finish: Hard enamel: smooth, glass-like, polished flat. Soft enamel: textured, slightly recessed, tactile.
- Durability: Hard enamel is more scratch-resistant and colorfast over time. Soft enamel can show wear on raised metal edges.
- Cost: Hard enamel typically costs more due to extra polishing steps. Soft enamel is usually more affordable. If budget is tight, soft enamel gives you a great look for less.
- Color vibrancy: Hard enamel allows for more saturated, even colors. Soft enamel colors can look slightly muted in the recessed areas.
Product facts
- Lesbian Pride Phoenix Enamel Pin: A large, striking enamel pin with bright, polished gold metal and hard enamel colors. Part of Royarach's Pride Heraldry series. Hard enamel gives this pin a smooth, glossy finish that makes the phoenix design and pride flag colors stand out vividly.
Lesbian Pride Phoenix Enamel Pin - Spotted Skunk Enamel Pin: A hard enamel pin of a spotted skunk, holding a little white flower charm. Gold-toned metal with enamel colors. The hard enamel surface keeps the skunk and flower charm looking crisp and polished, even with daily wear on a jacket or bag.
Spotted Skunk Enamel Pin
Which pin is right for you?
Best for
- Collectors who want a smooth, polished finish that lasts
- Anyone displaying pins on bags or jackets where durability matters
- Designs with fine details or multiple colors that benefit from a flat surface
Not for
- Shoppers on a tight budget who still want a quality pin
- People who prefer a handcrafted, dimensional look with visible metal lines
